Chik-Fil-A and UT
I want to thank Annabella Palopoli and the Minaret for reporting on the donations that the Chik-Fil-A corporation made to anti-equality groups operating here in the U.S. Knowledge is power — and after reading last week’s Minaret, I’m feeling empowered. I am reminded of some famous words spoken by Eleanor Roosevelt that GLTSBA, in years past, had used while tabling in Plant Hall and at freshmen orientation events:
“Where, after all, do universal human rights begin? In small places, close to home – so close and so small that they cannot be seen on any maps of the world. Yet they are the world of the individual person; the neighborhood he lives in; the school or college he attends; the factory, farm or office where he works.
Such are the places where every man, woman, and child seeks equal justice, equal opportunity, equal dignity without discrimination. Unless these rights have meaning there, they have little meaning anywhere. Without concerted citizen action to uphold them close to home, we shall look in vain for progress in the larger world.” [Emphasis mine.]
Ms. Palopoli was correct in characterizing the Ruth Institute, Focus on the Family, Exodus International and the others mentioned in the article as working to deny LGBT Americans full equality. What all these groups have in common is an irrational animus toward LGBT folk. They don’t want us to be visible; they don’t want to hear our voices; in fact, they’d prefer we disappear. The Family Research Council, in its own public statements, makes this sad fact evident.
The Family Research Council, according to 2009 IRS filings (the latest available), was a recipient of Chik-Fil-A’s generosity. Here is what Peter Sprigg, Senior Fellow for Policy Studies at the Family Research Council in Washington, D.C., had to say about gay youth being at-risk for suicide: “the most effective way of reducing teen suicide attempts is not to create a “positive social environment” for the affirmation of homosexuality. Instead, it would be to discourage teens from self-identifying as gay, lesbian, or bisexual.” Mr. Sprigg also called for the deportation LGBT residents in the U.S. He proclaimed, “I think there should be a place for criminal sanctions on homosexual behavior.” When asked on television if “gay behavior” (whatever that means) should be outlawed in the U.S., Sprigg replied, “Yes.”
So, Mr. Sprigg, exactly how would having a negative social environment, or no social environment, have helped Tyler Clementi, or Jamey Rodemeyer or other LGBT students who have taken their own lives? How will it help LGBT youth who, according to a recent Columbia University study, are five times more likely to attempt suicide than their heterosexual counterparts? It won’t.
But a “positive social environment” can and will. Our job here at UT is to create that environment, which requires visibility — not just visibility of LGBT students, faculty and administrators, but also of their friends and audible supporters.
Being informed and vigilant is important. The Minaret made me aware of Chik-Fil-A’s financial support for anti-equality groups. Chik-Fil-A won’t be getting any of my money and I will be passing the message on to others.
The groups funded by this fast-food franchise are so public, bald and blatant in their anti-equality statements, it’s easy to know what to do with the information. Unfortunately, many anti-gay sentiments are insidious and coded. Not long ago I was told: “You need to consider being less visible in certain controversial areas.” This was a reference to my advocacy for equality for our LGBT students. In fact, the statement proves that we all need to be more visible, then “It Gets Better” can be a reality and not just a YouTube message of hope.
“No one can make you feel inferior without your consent,” said Eleanor Roosevelt. I concur. Don’t consent.
Sincerely,
Gary S. Luter
Professor, Speech and Theatre
Director, Honors Program
Faculty Adviser, GLTSBA (Gay, Lesbian, Transgendered, Straight, Bisexual Alliance)

If I only patronized businesses that shared all my beliefs, I’d be left opening a store and buying things from myself. Even then, I still don’t agree with everything that I believe. Honestly, I’m a bit of a hypocrite, so I might have to shop around.
I suppose the issue is where one draws the line. Should I frequent a business where the owner is a known Republican voter while I prefer the Independent party? Can I turn a blind eye to the slave labor of a clothing chain because their pants fit oh-so-well around my uniquely shaped hips and posterior? Should I buy products from a country that supports terrorism, communism, or your preferred -ism of distaste?
I’m not saying one shouldn’t patronize a business that contradicts one’s moral values. Excuse my double negative, but I’m saying one shouldn’t not patronize a business simply because it goes against a moral value of one’s own. You personally should draw the line for what’s acceptable to you, what you can turn a blind eye to, and what you will not endorse. To think that anyone can do business somewhere that is completely alined with one’s ethics and tastes is utopian at best, but worse naive.
Will you buy a sandwich from Chick-Fil-A though you oppose anti-gay sentiments and laws? If you won’t, good for you. If you will, that’s fine, too.
You mentioned that not long ago you was told: “You need to consider being less visible in certain controversial areas.” Maybe you need to listen the them!? Not everyone feels the same way you do…
Dr. Luter,
Thanks for the well-written commentary. I agreed with the original article and I agree with yours. It is just sad that a company would support any organization that would deny others the rights due to all human beings.
Keep doing what you are doing.
-With Honors.
Why does it matter who they support? If you don’t like it, don’t eat there. There are plenty of others who feel the same way they do, or who simply could care less. Why try and ruin it for others? We live in America. Not everyone believes the same way, and just because one group thinks the other one is harming them doesn’t necessarily mean the rest of the country believes the same way. By all means, protest or stand up for your beliefs, just quit trying to cram them down my throat.
Phil Quintet (Is that your real name? Do I know you? Who are you?), why do you assume I didn’t “stand up”?
When told, “You need to consider being less visible . . . ,” my immediate spoken response was, “I’m not going back into the closet and if that’s a problem for the university then terminate me from my position.” Well, I wasn’t terminated and I’m still visible, obviously; still working with our LGBT students to bring about positive change on campus.
By the way, Phil, tomorrow, Monday, November 21, GLTSBA is sponsoring UT’s observance of Transgender Remembrance Day at the Sykes Chapel, 8:00 PM.
Transgender Remembrance Day is a day to memorialize those killed due to the hatred and fear of transgender individuals, and to bring attention to the continued violence endured by the transgender community. Those memorialized on this day were victims of violence based on the bias against transgender and gender nonconforming people. So, Phil, will I see you there?
Phil, you asked who I was “protecting.” Here’s the answer: I was protecting our LGBT students, colleagues and, of course, myself. We deserve to have our worth and dignity respected. You see, Phil, I know who I am. But I have no idea who you are.
Gary Luter
Chick-fil-A not only uses its corporate power to support a particular version of “family values” that hurt people who do not fit into this mold, the factory farm conditions in which it houses and kills its chickens are abhorrent. It’s a bad company and people who know about it and keep eating the chicken are complicit.
Of course Chick-Fil-A knows to whom they are donating. The company is run by a family that makes quite public their Christian faith. Part of that is obvious to all of us — why do you think all locations are closed on Sundays?
Gary,
who told you, “You need to consider being less visible in certain controversial areas”?
This person needs to be exposed for his/her bigotry. I would hate to think this type of incivility reaches to the top of the UT administration. Would you stand by if an African-American were told the same, or would you stand up to racism??
How is Chik-fil-a offensive, and this person(s) not? Call him/her out if you are truly offended.
Who are you protecting? Why?
Regardless of the fact I akin with millions of others will still eat their food. If this society wasn’t so hell bent on having to make donations this problem wouldn’t have occurred. I’m not saying donations are needed, but if there wasn’t such a need to companies to have them to look good for their customers this wouldn’t have happened. They have a right to support whoever they want. Man are these waffle fries good! You think all of your donations go where they are advertised, WAKE UP, only a small percentage actually does. Look up the Susan G Komen origination for the cure to breast cancer. Only a little actually goes to a cure.
Hey Do
Are you that naive to believe a corporation like Chik-Fil-A isn’t going to investigate an organization, and the causes such an organization supports, BEFORE they donate corporate funds…really? Really? REALLY? Maybe you had better take your own advise: “Do research” (You might want to check out Dominos Pizza, too)
They didn’t not know they were donating to said causes. They donated to an org who supported said anti functions. Why is everyone just looking to protest some stupid issue instead Or something that truly matters